New.Knife.Day

Home Categories Steel Comparisons Steels

100

POINTS

1 ROLL

AUS 8 vs VG 10 Knife Steel Comparison

AUS-8 vs VG-10: Which Steel Is Right for You?

Knife enthusiasts and collectors are always on the lookout for steels that strike the perfect balance between corrosion resistance, toughness, edge retention, and ease of sharpening. Two popular Japanese stainless steels—AUS-8 and VG-10—often appear on shortlists for everyday carry (EDC), bushcraft, and even kitchen knives. In this comprehensive post, we’ll explore the differences between AUS-8 and VG-10, examining their typical chemical compositions, heat-treatment considerations, ideal uses, and what each element in their alloy does. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which steel might be the best fit for your next knife.

Quick Tip: You’ll find AUS-8 prominently featured in older Cold Steel models, while VG-10 is famously used by brands like Spyderco (Seki City series) and Shun for kitchen knives.

1. Introduction to AUS-8 and VG-10

Both AUS-8 and VG-10 are Japanese stainless steels widely used in the knife industry. They share similarities (e.g., both can exhibit very good corrosion resistance) but have important differences in terms of edge retention and toughness.

AUS-8 Summary

Stainless steel known for good corrosion resistance and excellent ease of sharpening.
Often found in affordable and mid-tier knives.
Typical hardness ranges from around 57 to 59 HRC (depending on heat treatment).

VG-10 Summary

Premium Japanese stainless steel favored in many high-end kitchen knives and EDC blades.
Noted for its good edge retention, fine grain structure, and overall versatility.
Commonly hardened in the range of 59 to 61 HRC.

Note: These hardness ranges (AUS-8: ~57–59 HRC, VG-10: ~59–61 HRC) align with common industry standards.

2. Chemical Composition and Key Performance

Here are key performance comparisons based on commonly cited values:

Corrosion Resistance:
- AUS-8: Very good
- VG-10: Very good
Toughness:
- AUS-8: Good
- VG-10: Fair
Edge Retention:
- AUS-8: Fair
- VG-10: Good
Ease of Sharpening:
- AUS-8: Very good
- VG-10: Very good

While these summaries offer a quick reference, let’s explore the alloy elements in more detail.

SEO Note: Reiterating “AUS-8 vs VG-10” throughout helps search engines identify the topic.

3. Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Ranges and Practical Implications

AUS-8 Hardness Range (57–59 HRC):
- Easier to sharpen at slightly lower Rockwell hardness.
- Better toughness at lower hardness, minimizing chipping.
VG-10 Hardness Range (59–61 HRC):
- Enhanced edge retention due to higher hardness range.
- Can be more prone to potential edge chipping if the heat treatment is pushed toward the higher end.

In practical terms, AUS-8’s moderate hardness makes it a great choice for users who need a blade that is less likely to chip under stress (e.g., bushcraft or tactical scenarios). Meanwhile, VG-10’s higher hardness means it typically holds a sharper edge for a longer time, making it particularly attractive for kitchen work and EDC tasks.

4. Detailed Alloy Element Effects

Both AUS-8 and VG-10 obtain their core properties from a combination of elements. Actual percentages can vary slightly by manufacturer.

AUS-8 Core Elements (Approximate)

Carbon (0.7–0.75%): Contributes to hardness and edge retention.
Chromium (~13–14%): Helps with corrosion resistance and hardness.
Manganese (~0.5–1.0%): Aids hardenability, can slightly improve wear resistance.
Nickel (~0.5%): Improves toughness.
Vanadium (~0.18%): Refines grain structure, improving edge stability.
Silicon (~1.0%): Enhances strength and can improve oxidation resistance.
Molybdenum (~0.2%): Adds to overall hardness and wear resistance.

VG-10 Core Elements (Approximate)

Carbon (1.0%): Higher carbon contributes to better edge retention.
Chromium (15%): Broadens corrosion resistance and aids in high hardness.
Cobalt (1.4%): Boosts strength and hardness, often associated with a refined grain structure.
Molybdenum (1.05%): Improves hardness and pitting corrosion resistance.
Vanadium (0.2%): Assists in creating hard vanadium carbides for edge stability.
Manganese (0.5%) & Silicon (0.6%): Add toughness and some wear resistance.

Why Cobalt in VG-10? Cobalt can help achieve a finer grain structure, allowing higher hardness without too much loss in ductility.

5. Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging

AUS-8:
- Generally forgiving to heat-treat, maintaining consistency across 57–59 HRC.
- Less prone to warping or cracking compared to higher-carbon steels; a straightforward quench and temper cycle usually suffices.
- Normalizing cycles are less critical than for “super steel” formulas.
VG-10:
- Typically heat-treated around 59–61 HRC.
- Care must be taken by the maker to avoid overheating; at higher hardness, micro-chipping can occur if the blade geometry is thin or used for rough chores.
- Some makers employ multiple normalizing or sub-zero treatments to refine grain structure.

Neither steel is notorious for extreme warping or cracking issues, but VG-10 needs a bit more attention to reach higher hardness without compromising toughness.

6. Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Being stainless, both AUS-8 and VG-10 are less prone to patina compared to high-carbon steels like 1095 or W2. You typically won’t see dramatic color changes over time. Protective coatings (e.g., DLC, PVD) can be applied, but in most cases, the natural stain resistance of these steels is sufficient when proper cleaning and drying are practiced.

7. Real-World Performance Comparisons

A) Bushcraft and Survival

AUS-8:
- Good toughness and easy sharpening make it dependable for batoning, light chopping, and general camp chores.
- “Fair” edge retention means more frequent touch-ups, but it’s straightforward to get back to razor-sharpness.
VG-10:
- “Fair” toughness can lead to chipping during heavy impacts (e.g., batoning across hard knots).
- “Good” edge retention means it stays sharp longer for slicing and finer tasks—great if you’re also doing food prep in camp.

B) EDC (Everyday Carry)

AUS-8:
- Very good corrosion resistance for common EDC tasks like opening boxes and cutting rope.
- Less risk of chipping if you accidentally hit something like a staple.
VG-10:
- Retains a keen edge longer, ideal for users who sharpen less frequently.
- Also quite corrosion-resistant, so it tolerates daily humidity or occasional neglect.

C) Kitchen Knives

AUS-8:
- Highly resistant to staining and easy to sharpen.
- Excellent choice for home cooks who want low-maintenance knives.
VG-10:
- A top choice for high-end Japanese kitchen knives (e.g., Shun), thanks to a very sharp edge that stays sharper longer.
- “Fair” toughness is generally sufficient for slicing and chopping but can chip if used on bones or especially hard materials.

D) Tactical / Law Enforcement

AUS-8:
- Good toughness reduces the risk of catastrophic failure against hard targets.
- “Fair” edge retention requires more frequent touch-ups, but field maintenance is easy.
VG-10:
- Longer-lasting sharpness can be an advantage in high-pressure situations.
- Still relatively easy to sharpen, though micro-chipping can occur under extreme lateral stress.

Example Models:

AUS-8: Cold Steel SRK (older editions), SOG Twitch II (earlier runs).

VG-10: Spyderco Delica, Shun Classic series.

8. Maintenance, Ease of Sharpening, and Edge Care

One major benefit of both steels is their relatively easy sharpening compared to ultra-high wear-resistant steels (e.g., CPM S90V, Maxamet).

AUS-8 Maintenance Tips:
- Keep the blade clean and dry for maximum corrosion resistance.
- A small ceramic rod or pocket sharpener works well for quick field touch-ups.
- Regular stropping helps maintain a keen edge.
VG-10 Maintenance Tips:
- Wipe the blade dry after use, especially in saltwater environments.
- Micro-chips are possible if you cut extremely hard or abrasive materials; periodically inspect the edge.
- Light, frequent honing preserves the edge for longer intervals between major sharpenings.

9. Cost, Availability, and Market Reputation

AUS-8:
- Commonly found in budget to mid-range knives, with prices often ranging from $30 to $60 (depending on the brand).
- Respected for reliability, though no longer considered a top-tier steel in today’s market.
VG-10:
- Most often seen in mid-range to premium offerings, with many knives starting at around $60 and going upward of $100.
- Highly regarded in Japanese kitchen cutlery circles and by EDC enthusiasts who prize edge retention.

10. Pros and Cons of Each Steel

Below is a quick-reference table summarizing the pros and cons:

	AUS-8	VG-10
Corrosion Resistance	Very Good	Very Good
Toughness	Good	Fair
Edge Retention	Fair	Good
Ease of Sharpening	Very Good	Very Good
Typical Hardness (HRC)	~57–59	~59–61
Price Tier	Budget / Mid	Mid to Premium
Pros	- Easy to sharpen	- Good edge retention
	- Good toughness	- Good corrosion resistance
	- Very corrosion resistant	- Sharpens easily
	- More affordable
Cons	- Shorter edge life	- More prone to chipping if over-hardened
	- Less “prestige”	- Often pricier

11. Ideal Uses: Why Choose AUS-8 or VG-10?

AUS-8 Ideal Uses:
- Bushcraft/camping knives where impact toughness is beneficial.
- EDC knives for users who prefer a steel they can quickly touch up.
- Great for beginners due to affordability and easy sharpening.
VG-10 Ideal Uses:
- High-end kitchen knives, where a long-lasting keen edge is paramount.
- Folding knives for users who value edge retention yet want easy re-sharpening.
- Collectors who appreciate the prestige of a premium Japanese steel.

12. Conclusion and Recommendations

When deciding between AUS-8 and VG-10, consider what matters most for your intended use:

Choosing AUS-8
- Offers toughness, easy sharpening, and lower cost.
- Great for bushcraft, survival, and “rough and tumble” scenarios.
- Reliable and beginner-friendly, with very good corrosion resistance.
Choosing VG-10
- Provides better edge retention at a slightly higher price point.
- Excels in kitchen knives and EDC blades where long-lasting sharpness is key.
- While it has “fair” toughness, it’s still suitable for most daily cutting tasks.

Ultimately, both steels offer very good corrosion resistance and easy sharpening, so the best choice depends on whether you prioritize durability (AUS-8) or sharper, longer-lasting edges (VG-10). Whichever you select, you’ll find that these two Japanese steels have earned lasting respect in the knife community.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Which is better: AUS-8 or VG-10?

It depends on what you value most. If you need toughness and ease of sharpening and have a tighter budget, go with AUS-8. If you prefer enhanced edge retention and are willing to pay more, VG-10 is the superior choice.

2. Does VG-10 rust?

VG-10 is considered stainless and has high corrosion resistance. While it’s unlikely to rust with normal care, always wipe it dry and store it properly—especially after exposure to saltwater or acidic substances.

3. How often should I sharpen AUS-8 vs. VG-10?

AUS-8, with “fair” edge retention, may require more frequent touch-ups, especially under heavy use. VG-10 holds its edge longer, so you can go longer between sharpenings. However, the exact frequency depends on how you use and maintain your knife.

Final Note: Both AUS-8 and VG-10 deliver consistent, proven performance. Whichever steel you choose, keeping your blade clean, dry, and regularly maintained will ensure it serves you well for years to come.