New.Knife.Day

Home Categories Steel Comparisons Steels

100

POINTS

1 ROLL

CPM S30V vs CPM S35VN Knife Steel Comparison

Comparing CPM-S30V vs CPM-S35VN: Choosing the Right Premium Stainless Steel for Your Knife

If you’re a knife enthusiast or collector, chances are you’ve come across CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN—two high-end stainless steels produced by Crucible Industries. These premium knife steels consistently make “best of” lists for their excellent balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. But how do they differ in practice, and which one should you pick for your next blade? In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore their compositions, typical hardness ranges, heat-treatment nuances, and ideal uses in real-world applications. By the end, you’ll have a solid grasp of whether CPM-S30V or CPM-S35VN is the better choice for your needs.

1. Introduction to CPM-S30V

CPM-S30V, developed by Crucible Industries in the early 2000s, has been a game-changer in the knife world. With a carbon content of around 1.45%, a chromium content of about 14%, and additions of molybdenum and vanadium, CPM-S30V was specifically engineered to excel as a high-performance, premium knife steel.

Chemical Composition Highlights:
- Carbon (1.45%): Contributes to hardness and edge stability.
- Chromium (14%): Ensures very good corrosion resistance and aids in forming chromium carbides.
- Molybdenum (2%): Improves wear resistance and overall toughness.
- Vanadium (4%): Forms hard vanadium carbides, boosting edge retention.
Key Performance Characteristics:
- Corrosion Resistance: Very good
- Toughness: Fair
- Edge Retention: Good
- Ease of Sharpening: Good
Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Range:
- Around 58–61 HRC, commonly targeted at 59–60 HRC in production knives for a balance between toughness and edge holding.

2. Introduction to CPM-S35VN

CPM-S35VN was introduced as an evolution of CPM-S30V, developed in collaboration with Chris Reeve Knives. One of the main modifications was adding a small amount (~0.5%) of niobium, along with a slight tweak to the vanadium content. This change improved machinability and toughness, while retaining the excellent edge retention and corrosion resistance of its predecessor.

Chemical Composition Highlights:
- Carbon (1.38%): Slightly lower than S30V, contributing to a marginally easier sharpening experience.
- Chromium (14%): The same high level of chromium fosters very good corrosion resistance.
- Molybdenum (2%): Assists in wear resistance and overall strength.
- Vanadium (3%) + Niobium (0.5%): Work together to refine grain size and enhance toughness.
Key Performance Characteristics:
- Corrosion Resistance: Very good
- Toughness: Good
- Edge Retention: Good
- Ease of Sharpening: Good
Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Range:
- Around 58–61 HRC, similar to S30V. Many makers aim for 59–60 HRC for a user-friendly balance of performance.

3. Detailed Alloy Element Effects

Understanding what each element contributes can help you appreciate why S30V and S35VN perform the way they do:

Carbon (C): Provides hardness, edge stability, and overall strength. In these steels, carbon content is typically in the 1.3–1.45% range, high enough for superior edge retention.
Chromium (Cr): At 14% for both steels, chromium is crucial for “stainless” properties, forming chromium carbides that offer excellent corrosion resistance.
Molybdenum (Mo): Typically around 2%, it increases hardness, high-temperature strength, and wear resistance.
Vanadium (V): Key for wear resistance and the formation of very hard vanadium carbides, significantly improving edge retention.
Niobium (Nb) [in S35VN]: Refines the microstructure, improving toughness without compromising wear resistance. This is the primary difference between S30V and S35VN.

4. Typical Hardness Ranges and Practical Implications

CPM-S30V HRC ~ 58–61
- At the higher end of this range, the steel gains better edge retention but might lose some toughness.
- Most production knives choose ~59–60 HRC, offering a good compromise between durability, ease of sharpening, and wear resistance.
CPM-S35VN HRC ~ 58–61
- Similar range, but the niobium addition helps sustain better toughness at comparable hardness levels.
- Many knifemakers also aim for 59–60 HRC for a balanced performance, though some push it to 61 HRC for a crisper edge.

5. Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging

CPM powder-metallurgy steels like S30V and S35VN are typically produced via stock removal rather than forging. However, some bladesmiths do forge them, requiring extra caution:

Warping & Cracking Risk: Both steels are more stable than certain high-carbon or high-vanadium tool steels, but consistent, stepwise preheating is recommended.
Normalizing & Annealing: These steps should be followed carefully and in line with Crucible’s guidelines to avoid grain growth or uneven hardness.
Heat-Treatment Profile: Quenching from the specified austenitizing temperature and optional cryogenic treatment can maximize wear resistance and hardness. Tempering is done in 2–3 cycles for stability.

6. Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Because both CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN contain 14% chromium, they are classified as stainless. They do not readily form patinas like high-carbon steels (e.g., 1095, O1, W2). Instead, they generally remain bright or develop only minor discoloration under extreme or neglectful conditions.

Patina Formation: Highly unlikely in normal use; serious patina might only form if the blade is left uncleaned for an extended period in corrosive environments.
Protective Coatings: Typically not necessary thanks to excellent corrosion resistance. Some prefer coatings to reduce glare or add an extra barrier in marine or salty environments, but it’s optional.

7. Practical Performance Comparison

Below is a quick-reference table comparing how CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN perform in key areas:

	CPM-S30V	CPM-S35VN
Corrosion Resistance	Very Good	Very Good
Toughness	Fair	Good
Edge Retention	Good	Good
Ease of Sharpening	Good	Good
Typical Hardness	58–61 HRC	58–61 HRC

Specific Applications

Bushcraft & Survival
- S30V: Excellent edge retention for extended cutting tasks; can be slightly more prone to micro-chipping when batoning or striking knots.
- S35VN: Better toughness, making it more forgiving in demanding outdoor scenarios.
EDC (Everyday Carry)
- Both steels: Ideal for daily carry, offering great rust resistance. If you often pry or twist with your blade, S35VN’s added toughness may be beneficial.
Kitchen Use
- Both steels: Their high corrosion resistance makes them well-suited for kitchen environments. S35VN might be marginally less prone to chipping if you hit bone or accidentally drop the blade.
Tactical or Heavy-Duty Tasks
- S35VN: Slightly better impact resistance, ideal for more extreme conditions.
- S30V: Still robust and widely used, but it’s less forgiving under critical stress or lateral loads.

8. Ease of Sharpening, Chipping Risk, and Wear Resistance

Ease of Sharpening: Generally, both are considered “good” to sharpen, though many find S35VN a bit simpler to return to razor sharpness due to its finer grain structure. A typical sharpening angle of 17–20 degrees per side is recommended for EDC tasks, while 20–25 degrees per side may be chosen for harder-use knives.
Chipping Risk: S30V can be slightly more prone to micro-chips if used on very hard materials (e.g., nails, wire). S35VN’s added niobium and refined structure mitigate this risk somewhat.
Wear Resistance: Both have high vanadium content, which confers good wear resistance. Most users will rarely notice a difference in maintenance intervals between the two.

9. Cost, Availability, and Maintenance

Cost: Although S35VN was meant to be easier to manufacture (and sometimes more affordable), market conditions often lead to similar pricing between S30V and S35VN.
Availability: Major knife companies—Spyderco, Benchmade, Chris Reeve Knives, Zero Tolerance—offer models in both steels. Custom makers also use them extensively.
Maintenance: Basic knife care—cleaning, drying, and occasional oiling—is sufficient. Rust is unlikely unless the blade is severely neglected.

10. Ideal Uses and Why Choose One Over the Other?

CPM-S30V

Ideal Uses: EDC folders, hunting knives, and general outdoor tasks.
Why Pick It? If you want a proven, widely available, and balanced premium knife steel, S30V remains a top industry standard.

CPM-S35VN

Ideal Uses: Hard-use folders, bushcraft knives, camp knives, or tasks demanding extra toughness.
Why Pick It? If you routinely engage in heavy-duty cutting, batoning, or prying—or you value an easier sharpening experience—S35VN’s additional toughness is a worthwhile upgrade.

11. Pros and Cons

CPM-S30V Pros

Excellent combination of wear resistance and corrosion resistance
Good edge retention for most cutting jobs
Highly popular and widely adopted by major manufacturers

CPM-S30V Cons

Toughness is fair, so it can chip under heavy stress
Slightly more prone to micro-chipping than S35VN

CPM-S35VN Pros

Improved toughness compared to S30V
Very good corrosion resistance and overall edge retention
Typically easier to machine and sharpen
Niobium addition refines grain structure

CPM-S35VN Cons

Priced similarly or slightly higher than S30V, so not always a budget alternative
If you don’t push your blade too hard, you may not notice its added toughness

12. Market Reputation and Factory Heat Treat Variations

Market Reputation: S30V was long considered the gold standard for high-end production knives. S35VN quickly gained wide acceptance for its incremental improvements, in part due to endorsement by Chris Reeve Knives.
Heat Treat Variations: Different knife manufacturers or custom makers may run these steels at slightly different hardness levels. Many target 59–60 HRC, but some experiment with higher ranges to eke out more edge retention, accepting a small trade-off in toughness.

13. Conclusion and Recommendations

When choosing between CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN, think about your typical usage scenarios:

Best for Toughness and Durability: CPM-S35VN is your go-to if you expect heavy-duty tasks like batoning or prying. Its improved toughness helps minimize chipping and extends the blade’s lifespan under abuse.
Best Overall Balance for EDC: Both steels shine in everyday carry roles, but if ease of sharpening or a bit more forgiveness is important, S35VN has a slight edge.
Proven Classic: CPM-S30V remains a reliable choice for anyone seeking a premium knife steel that excels in edge retention and corrosion resistance without breaking the bank.

Overall, both CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN offer excellent corrosion resistance, good edge retention, and decent ease of sharpening. If you value extra toughness for serious outdoor tasks, go with S35VN. If you want a time-tested, widely accessible option that won’t disappoint, S30V is still outstanding.

Note: CPM-S45VN is now another iteration in the same family, boasting further refinements. However, CPM-S30V and CPM-S35VN remain industry benchmarks that cater to a wide variety of cutting needs.

14. FAQ

1) Is S35VN better than S30V?

“S35VN vs. S30V” is one of the most common questions among knife enthusiasts. The answer depends on your intended use. S35VN is generally tougher and slightly easier to sharpen, so if you’re dealing with heavy-duty tasks or want added durability, it’s worth considering.

2) Does one hold an edge significantly longer?

In practical EDC or hunting tasks, both steels have similarly high edge retention due to their vanadium carbides. The difference is often negligible unless you’re doing extremely abrasive cutting.

3) What are recommended sharpening angles?

For typical EDC or kitchen use, 17–20 degrees per side is a popular choice, balancing sharpness and durability. For heavy-duty or bushcraft use, some prefer 20–25 degrees per side to reduce the risk of chipping.

4) Did Chris Reeve Knives have a role in S35VN’s development?

Yes. Chris Reeve Knives collaborated with Crucible Industries, adding niobium and slightly adjusting the composition of S30V to create S35VN, aiming for improved toughness and easier finishing.

5) Is there a newer steel in this family?

Yes, CPM-S45VN and other new steels (like Magnacut) have entered the market. They build upon the successes of S30V and S35VN with additional tweaks to the composition for enhanced overall performance.

Additional SEO & Reference Tips

• Use key phrases like "CPM-S30V vs CPM-S35VN," "premium knife steel," and "high-end stainless steel" throughout your content to drive search engine visibility.
• Link to authoritative sources, such as official Crucible datasheets or popular knife maker websites, to improve credibility.

By understanding their compositions, heat-treatment ranges, edge angle considerations, and typical hardness levels, you now know precisely why these steels behave the way they do—and which one fits your lifestyle, whether you’re cooking in the kitchen, carrying a pocket knife daily, or tackling tough outdoor adventures.