New.Knife.Day

Home Categories Steel Comparisons Steels

CPM SPY27 vs CPM S35VN Knife Steel Comparison

Introduction

When it comes to premium knife steels, few names garner as much respect as Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM). Among these modern “super steels,” CPM-SPY27 and CPM-S35VN are two that have gained widespread popularity for their impressive balance of edge retention, toughness, corrosion resistance, and ease of sharpening. Whether you’re a collector, chef, bushcrafter, or just an everyday carry (EDC) enthusiast looking for the best knife steel in a premium EDC knife, both steels offer “very good” corrosion resistance, “good” toughness, “good” edge retention, and “good” ease of sharpening. However, each has its unique attributes that might make it the better choice depending on your specific needs and preferences. This article provides a detailed CPM-SPY27 vs CPM-S35VN comparison—covering chemical composition, heat treatment, hardness ranges, patina formation, and more—so you can make an informed decision for your next knife purchase.

1. Understanding CPM-SPY27

1.1 Chemical Composition and Alloy Element Effects

Carbon (~1.27%): Increases hardness and edge retention.
Chromium (~14%): Improves corrosion resistance and contributes to stainless properties.
Cobalt (~1.5%): Aids in grain refinement and can enhance hardness and edge stability.
Manganese (~0.5%): Assists in hardness and wear resistance when used in moderation.
Molybdenum (~2%): Enhances hardenability, strength, and corrosion resistance.
Niobium (~0.9–1%): Promotes a fine grain structure and boosts wear resistance.
Nitrogen (~0.1%): Contributes to edge stability.
Silicon (~0.5%): Improves overall strength.
Vanadium (~1–2%): Further boosts wear resistance and refines the grain, leading to better edge stability.
Tungsten (~1%): Sometimes present to improve wear resistance and hardness stability (may be batch-dependent).

This proprietary focus on niobium, cobalt, and vanadium gives CPM-SPY27 a well-rounded balance of properties, making it relatively easy to sharpen while maintaining a solid edge.

1.2 Heat Treatment Ranges and Typical Hardness (HRC)

Typical HRC Range: ~59–61
Practical Implication: Within this range, CPM-SPY27 exhibits “good” toughness and “very good” corrosion resistance. It also achieves “good” edge retention without becoming too brittle, suitable for tasks that involve repeated slicing.

1.3 Key Performance Characteristics

Corrosion Resistance: Very good. With around 14% chromium, it resists rusting well, even in humid or marine environments.
Toughness: Good. It withstands a range of impact tasks without chipping or rolling excessively.
Edge Retention: Good. Fine-grained carbides formed by vanadium, niobium, and possibly tungsten contribute to its abrasion resistance.
Ease of Sharpening: Good. Cobalt and niobium aid in forming a fine grain structure, making re-sharpening more manageable than with some higher-carbide steels.

1.4 Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging Considerations

Normalizing or Stress-Relief Cycles: Although CPM-SPY27 isn’t notoriously difficult to heat treat, most reputable makers apply multiple stress-relief steps for optimal hardness and toughness.
Warping/Cracking: Not especially prone to warping or cracking when treated properly. However, as with all powdered steels, tight temperature control is crucial.
Cryogenic Treatment: Many makers utilize cryo (dry ice or liquid nitrogen) treatments between quenching and tempering to refine the microstructure and improve final hardness and toughness.

1.5 Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Because of its stainless-level chromium content (~14%) and additional alloying, CPM-SPY27 does not typically form a patina with normal use. Coatings like Diamond-Like Carbon (DLC) or PVD would mainly be for scratch resistance or aesthetics rather than corrosion prevention.

2. Understanding CPM-S35VN

2.1 Chemical Composition and Alloy Element Effects

Carbon (1.38%): Enhances hardness, wear resistance, and edge retention.
Chromium (14%): Ensures stainless capabilities and good corrosion resistance.
Molybdenum (2%): Boosts hardenability and corrosion resistance.
Niobium (~0.5%): Refines the grain structure and enhances wear resistance.
Vanadium (3%): Significantly increases wear resistance and hardenability.

Developed by Crucible Industries and Chris Reeve Knives as an evolution of CPM-S30V, CPM-S35VN includes niobium for a more refined grain structure, improving overall toughness and making the steel easier to sharpen than its predecessor.

2.2 Heat Treatment Ranges and Typical Hardness (HRC)

Typical HRC Range: ~58–60 (sometimes up to 61 for specialized blades)
Practical Implication: This balance offers “good” toughness and “very good” corrosion resistance while maintaining “good” edge retention. It’s a go-to choice for many mid- to high-end production knives.

2.3 Key Performance Characteristics

Corrosion Resistance: Very good. The 14% chromium content ensures strong rust resistance.
Toughness: Good. Tougher than S30V, making it a favorite for hard-use folders and fixed blades.
Edge Retention: Good. Its refined carbide structure helps keep edges keen for extended use.
Ease of Sharpening: Good. Niobium helps control the total carbide volume, making it more user-friendly for sharpening compared to ultra-high-carbide steels.

2.4 Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging Considerations

Stress-Relief and Tempering: Proper protocols ensure a stable and optimized microstructure.
Warping/Cracking: Can show slight distortion if not quenched correctly but is less finicky than older stainless steels.
Cryogenic Treatment: Often used to maximize hardness and wear resistance, while still retaining adequate toughness.

2.5 Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Like CPM-SPY27, CPM-S35VN resists patina formation. Coatings like DLC or PVD are optional for scratch resistance or aesthetics.

3. Side-by-Side Comparison

	CPM-SPY27	CPM-S35VN
Corrosion Resistance	Very Good	Very Good
Toughness	Good	Good
Edge Retention	Good	Good
Ease of Sharpening	Good	Good
Typical HRC Range	59–61	58–60 (up to 61)

4. Real-World Applications

4.1 Bushcraft and Survival

CPM-SPY27: Its balanced toughness helps with tasks like batoning or feather-stick making. Good edge retention and corrosion resistance suit wet or humid environments.
CPM-S35VN: Also excels in bushcraft. Takes a fine edge, retains it well, and remains relatively easy to sharpen in the field.

4.2 Everyday Carry (EDC)

CPM-SPY27: A premium EDC steel choice for pocket knives or multi-purpose blades. Its moderate hardness range handles tasks like cutting cardboard, rope, or light packaging without frequent sharpening.
CPM-S35VN: A longstanding favorite for EDC because of its consistent performance, strong stainless properties, and broad availability across many knife brands.

4.3 Kitchen Use

CPM-SPY27: Excellent rust prevention, easy maintenance, and a polished appearance that won’t patina readily—ideal for kitchen knives.
CPM-S35VN: Popular among custom culinary knife makers. Resists chipping and is easy to re-sharpen for the busy kitchen environment.

4.4 Tactical and Hard Use

CPM-SPY27: Its good toughness helps withstand lateral stress or quick impacts (prying, stabbing).
CPM-S35VN: Well-suited for tactical or military blades, offering reliable performance under stress with less risk of brittle failure.

5. Why Pick These Steels Over Other Options?

Balanced Properties: Both CPM-SPY27 and CPM-S35VN offer a superior blend of wear resistance, corrosion resistance, toughness, and ease of sharpening compared to many lower-tier steels.
Versatility: They handle EDC tasks, bushcraft, survival, and even tactical roles effectively.
Market Reputation: CPM-S35VN is widely hailed as one of the best knife steel options, with a longstanding track record. CPM-SPY27 is newer but is steadily proving its worth, particularly in Spyderco proprietary steel applications.

6. Maintenance, Cost, and Availability

Cost: CPM-S35VN is relatively common in mid- to high-end production and custom knives. CPM-SPY27 often appears in Spyderco models, potentially making it pricier or more specialized.
Availability: CPM-S35VN is widespread among various brands. CPM-SPY27 primarily appears in certain Spyderco models, though other makers may adopt it in the future.
Maintenance: Both steels require minimal upkeep. A simple wipe-down and occasional oiling (if desired) suffice due to their very good corrosion resistance.

7. Pros and Cons of Each Steel

7.1 CPM-SPY27

Pros

Very good corrosion resistance—excellent in humid or marine conditions.
Balanced edge retention with easier sharpening.
Can reach slightly higher hardness (59–61 HRC), offering a crisp edge.
Good toughness for tasks like bushcraft or wilderness use.

Cons

Less widely available outside of Spyderco’s lineup.
Slightly less historical data for custom makers to reference (compared to older steels).

7.2 CPM-S35VN

Pros

Well-established with numerous knife brands—proven track record.
Very good corrosion resistance.
Good toughness without being overly brittle.
Good edge retention and relatively straightforward sharpening.

Cons

Less “exotic” for collectors seeking something unique.
Specialized blades at higher HRC may require more skill to sharpen.

8. Heat Treatment Nuances and Forging

Neither CPM-SPY27 nor CPM-S35VN is especially prone to warping or cracking, but both are powdered, high-alloy stainless steels requiring precise heat treatment:

Austenitizing Temperatures: ~1950–2050°F (1065–1120°C).
Quenching: Must be carefully managed to minimize distortion.
Cryogenic Treatment: Frequently used after quenching to refine grain and maximize hardness and wear resistance.
Tempering: Multiple tempering cycles help achieve the targeted hardness and optimize toughness.
Professional Heat Treatment: Strongly recommended, especially for knives where peak performance is critical.

9. Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Both steels have ~14% chromium and are classified as stainless. They won’t form a natural patina like high-carbon steels (e.g., 1095, O1) under typical use conditions. Optional coatings (DLC, PVD) mainly serve to enhance scratch resistance or add visual flair.

10. Conclusion and Recommendations

CPM-SPY27 and CPM-S35VN are both top-tier stainless steels—among the best knife steels available—that knife enthusiasts and collectors can trust for “very good” corrosion resistance, “good” toughness, “good” edge retention, and “good” ease of sharpening. They shine in everyday tasks as well as in more demanding roles like bushcraft or tactical use.

Choose CPM-SPY27 if you want a slightly higher achievable hardness, are intrigued by Spyderco proprietary steel, and value a unique mix of cobalt, niobium, vanadium, and possibly tungsten. Its easy maintenance and stable edge make it a favorite among Spyderco fans.
Choose CPM-S35VN if you want a proven performer with broad availability and a long-established track record. It’s often considered one of the best all-around premium EDC steels, available from countless brands and custom makers.

Either way, both steels represent modern metallurgy’s pinnacle of performance, providing knives that retain sharp edges, resist corrosion, and stand up to rigorous use.

FAQs and Final Notes

Which Steel Is Better?

Neither steel is outright “better” for every purpose. If you want a slightly harder edge and appreciate Spyderco’s designs, go with CPM-SPY27. If you prefer wide availability and a proven track record across multiple brands, CPM-S35VN might fit you best.

How Often Do These Steels Need Sharpening?

Sharpening frequency varies with use. Both steels can go extended periods without dulling under moderate daily tasks. Regular stropping or light honing can prolong time between full sharpenings.

Does Blade Geometry Matter?

Absolutely. Real-world performance also depends on blade geometry, grind type, and the maker’s skill in heat treatment. Even the best steel can perform poorly if the knife’s design isn’t well-executed.

Where to Find More Technical Data?

Refer to manufacturer datasheets from Crucible Industries or Spyderco for the most up-to-date information on composition, recommended heat treatment protocols, and performance testing. These documents provide deeper technical insights for custom knifemakers and curious enthusiasts.

By following professional heat-treatment guidelines and maintaining your knives with simple care, you’ll enjoy the exceptional performance these steels offer—making either CPM-SPY27 or CPM-S35VN a stellar choice for your next premium EDC knife or bushcraft companion.