New.Knife.Day

Home Categories Steel Comparisons Steels

100

POINTS

1 ROLL

D2 vs M390 Knife Steel Comparison

Introduction

For knife enthusiasts and collectors, understanding the nuances between different steels can make all the difference when selecting a blade for everyday carry (EDC), bushcraft, kitchen tasks, or tactical applications. Two steels that often come up in conversations are D2 and M390. Both are well-respected, but they suit different user preferences and performance needs. This comprehensive guide will walk you through their chemical compositions, heat treatment ranges, performance characteristics, and real-world applications. By the end, you’ll have a solid grasp of which steel is a better fit for you—especially if you’re comparing “D2 vs M390” for your next knife purchase.

1. Overview of D2 Steel

D2 is an air-hardening, semi-stainless tool steel known for its balance of hardness and corrosion resistance. It generally contains around 1.55% carbon, 11.5% chromium, 0.9% molybdenum, and 0.8% vanadium (among other elements). This composition positions it between true stainless steels and simpler high-carbon steels.

1.1 Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Range

D2 typically reaches between 58–61 HRC after heat treatment.
At these hardness levels, D2 offers a strong balance of cutting performance and overall durability.

1.2 Key Performance Characteristics of D2

Corrosion Resistance: Good. Although not fully stainless, the moderate chromium content gives it above-average rust resistance compared to simple carbon steels.
Toughness: Fair. D2’s higher carbon content and air-hardening properties reduce its overall toughness compared to some other tool steels, but it’s still acceptable for most general knife tasks.
Edge Retention: Good. The presence of carbon and vanadium carbides helps the steel hold a keen edge for a reasonable period.
Ease of Sharpening: Good. While it’s harder than simpler steels (like 1095), most users find D2 manageable to sharpen with the right equipment.

2. Overview of M390 Steel

M390 is a premium powder-metallurgy steel renowned for its high-end performance in both corrosion resistance and edge retention. Its typical composition includes about 1.9% carbon, 20% chromium, 1% molybdenum, 0.6% tungsten, and 4% vanadium. This combination creates a finely grained steel with well-distributed carbides.

Note: M390 has near-identical equivalents: CPM 20CV (Crucible) and CTS 204P (Carpenter). If you see those names, expect comparable performance.

2.1 Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Range

M390’s typical hardness falls around 59–61 HRC (some manufacturers push it to 62 HRC, and in certain custom treatments, it can reach 63–64 HRC).
It maintains excellent wear resistance even at these higher hardness levels, making it a go-to choice for high-performance knives.

2.2 Key Performance Characteristics of M390

Corrosion Resistance: Excellent. High chromium (about 20%) ensures that M390 is considered a true stainless steel, making it very resistant to rust and staining.
Toughness: Fair. Despite its high hardness, M390’s powder-metallurgy process helps maintain decent toughness, but it isn’t meant for extreme impact or prying tasks.
Edge Retention: Very Good. M390’s wear resistance is one of its standout features, allowing it to keep a razor-sharp edge for extended periods.
Ease of Sharpening: Good. Some high-carbide stainless steels are notoriously difficult to sharpen, but M390’s fine microstructure makes it comparatively more user-friendly than many steels at its performance level. That said, beginners may find D2 slightly easier to sharpen overall.

3. Detailed Alloy Element Effects

Understanding alloy elements can help you see why D2 and M390 behave the way they do:

3.1 Key Elements in D2

Carbon (1.55%): High carbon content increases hardness and wear resistance.
Chromium (11.5%): Adds corrosion resistance and helps form chromium carbides for edge retention.
Molybdenum (0.9%): Improves strength and wear resistance, enhances hardenability.
Vanadium (0.8%): Contributes to wear resistance by forming hard vanadium carbides.

3.2 Key Elements in M390

Carbon (1.9%): Offers a high potential hardness and excellent wear resistance.
Chromium (20%): Makes M390 extremely rust-resistant, forming a strong protective chromium oxide layer.
Molybdenum (1%): Enhances strength and wear resistance, working synergistically with vanadium and tungsten.
Tungsten (0.6%): Increases abrasion resistance and toughness at high hardness levels.
Vanadium (4%): Significantly boosts wear resistance due to the formation of very hard vanadium carbides.

4. Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging

4.1 D2 Heat Treatment and Forging Nuances

Air-Hardening: D2 is known for air-hardening, which can be more forgiving than water quenching, but it still requires precise temperature control to achieve optimal hardness and stress relief.
Potential for Warping or Cracking: Without careful thermal cycling, D2 can become prone to distortion. It’s advisable to use normalizing cycles and slow, consistent cooling to minimize warping.
Forging Challenges: Due to its increased chromium content and higher carbon, D2 can be challenging to forge and is often used in stock-removal knife making rather than extensive forging.

4.2 M390 Heat Treatment and Forging Nuances

Specialized Heat Treatment: M390, being a powder-metallurgy steel, is often best handled by professionals with access to precise temperature control. Ramp-up times, soak temperatures, and cryogenic treatments are critical to maximize hardness and corrosion resistance.
Not Commonly Forged: Most M390 blades are made via stock removal (CNC machining or grinding) because forging powder-metallurgy steels can be more complex and rarely yields significant advantages. However, a few custom knife makers do forge M390, albeit with specialized equipment and processes.

5. Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

5.1 D2 Patina Formation

Semi-Stainless: Although D2 has good corrosion resistance for a tool steel, it can still form a light patina if exposed to acidic or high-moisture environments for prolonged periods. Over time, a patina may develop, offering limited additional corrosion protection.
Protective Coatings: Some knife makers coat D2 blades (e.g., with DLC or Cerakote) to further improve corrosion resistance, especially in humid or salty conditions.

5.2 M390 Patina Formation

True Stainless: With excellent corrosion resistance, M390 is unlikely to form a noticeable patina under normal use. You’d have to expose it to extreme conditions or neglect cleaning it for a very long time to see any discoloration.
Coatings: Coatings on M390 are typically for aesthetics or enhanced wear resistance rather than for corrosion protection, since the steel already has an excellent resistance to rust.

6. Ideal Uses: Why Pick One Over the Other?

6.1 D2’s Ideal Uses

Hard-Use EDC: If you want a knife that can hold a good edge, be relatively easy to resharpen, and handle day-to-day tasks without rapid rusting, D2 is a solid, budget-friendlier option.
Bushcraft and Outdoor: D2’s good edge retention allows for extended time in the field before sharpening, though care is needed to protect it from rust in wet conditions.
Larger Fixed Blades: Many D2 blades appear in fixed-blade designs where the combination of wear resistance and decent toughness is valued, although truly heavy-duty tasks might benefit from a tougher steel.

6.2 M390’s Ideal Uses

Premium EDC: M390 excels in corrosion resistance and edge retention, making it perfect for high-end folding knives and daily carry where minimal maintenance is desired.
Kitchen Tasks: Its excellent stain resistance and wear resistance make it suitable for kitchen knives, although frequent contact with acidic foods is no challenge for M390.
Tactical and Survival: M390 remains reliable in harsh environments, thanks to its corrosion resistance, though it has only fair toughness for extremely abusive tasks like prying.

7. Side-by-Side Comparison Table

	D2	M390
Corrosion Resistance	Good	Excellent
Toughness	Fair	Fair
Edge Retention	Good	Very Good
Ease of Sharpening	Good	Good (slightly tougher for beginners)
Typical HRC Range	58–61	59–61 (up to 62–64)
Price & Availability	More Affordable and Readily Found	More Expensive, Seen in Premium Knives

8. Pros and Cons of Each Steel

8.1 D2 Pros

Good edge retention and fairly easy sharpening process.
Cost-effective compared to many high-end stainless steels.
Better corrosion resistance than simple carbon steels due to moderate chromium content.

8.2 D2 Cons

Only fair toughness; not ideal for extreme impact or continuous heavy batoning.
Prone to forming light patina or rust spots if neglected in very moist environments.
Heat treatment requires careful control to avoid warping.

8.3 M390 Pros

Excellent corrosion resistance, making maintenance simpler.
Very good edge retention, especially for slicing and long-lasting sharpness.
Good ease of sharpening for a high-carbide, powder-based stainless steel (and easier than many super-steels like S90V or S110V).

8.4 M390 Cons

Tends to be more expensive due to the complex manufacturing process.
Fair toughness means it’s not the top choice for repeated heavy-impact tasks.
Potentially requires professional-level heat treatment for best performance.

9. Cost, Availability, and Maintenance

Cost: D2 is generally more wallet-friendly, while M390 knives typically cost more due to the steel’s premium nature and advanced manufacturing.
Availability: D2 is widely used by many manufacturers and custom makers due to its proven track record. M390, though increasingly popular, is still considered a premium choice seen in mid-range to higher-end production or custom knives.
Maintenance: Neither steel should be neglected, but M390’s excellent corrosion resistance allows you to worry less about moisture. D2 knives benefit from wiping the blade dry and occasionally applying a light coat of oil to prevent any rust.

10. Conclusions and Recommendations

Both D2 and M390 are strong performers, but your ideal choice depends on your specific needs and budget:

If you want a hard-working steel that offers good edge retention, good corrosion resistance, and a friendlier price point, D2 is a time-tested option. Make sure to provide basic maintenance and mind its fair toughness during rough use.
If you’re after top-tier corrosion resistance, very good edge retention, and are willing to pay a premium for a more refined steel, then M390 is worth the investment. It’s well-suited for EDC blades where minimal upkeep is a priority and retaining a super-sharp edge is paramount.

Quick “Which One Is Right for Me?” Summary

• Pick D2 if:

You’re budget-conscious.
You don’t mind routine blade care to prevent rust.
You’re looking for a reliable, proven tool steel for general use.

• Pick M390 if:

You need top-level corrosion resistance for humid or wet environments.
You want extended edge retention and minimal sharpening.
A higher price tag is acceptable for premium performance.

Final Word

When deciding between D2 and M390, consider the typical tasks you’ll face and your enthusiasm for maintaining a blade. For an entry-level or budget-minded collector, D2 can satisfy most daily cutting needs with proper care. For the aficionado seeking advanced performance and minimal upkeep, M390 represents one of the best stainless steels on the market. Either steel can serve you well for years, adding functional diversity to any knife collection.

In real-world use, many enthusiasts praise M390 for staying “hair-popping” sharp longer than D2, though D2 can be quicker to re-sharpen with simpler sharpening tools. Ultimately, there’s no wrong choice—both stand as proven options in the world of modern knife steels.

Stay sharp, and enjoy your new knife!