D2 vs N690 Knife Steel Comparison

D2 vs N690 Steel – Comprehensive Guide for Knife Enthusiasts

Below is a comprehensive guide comparing D2 and N690 steels, designed for knife enthusiasts and collectors who want to understand the nuances of these two popular blade materials. From chemical composition and heat treatment to real-world performance, this article will help you decide which steel suits your knife requirements best.

---

1. INTRODUCTION

Steel choice is one of the most critical factors when purchasing or designing a knife. Different alloys exhibit unique properties—such as corrosion resistance, edge retention, and toughness—all influenced by their chemical composition and heat-treat procedures. Two steels often compared in the knife community are D2 and N690.

• D2 is a high-carbon, high-chromium tool steel known for its excellent wear resistance and “semi-stainless” status.
• N690 is a stainless steel produced by Böhler (an Austrian steel manufacturer), prized for its higher chromium content and well-balanced attributes, particularly in corrosion resistance and sharpenability.

In the following sections, we’ll break down their compositions, performance characteristics, heat treatment considerations, and overall suitability for various knife applications.

---

2. CHEMICAL COMPOSITION

2.1 D2 Steel Composition

According to reference data, D2 typically contains approximately:

• 1.55% Carbon (C)
• 11.5% Chromium (Cr)
• 0.35% Manganese (Mn)
• 0.9% Molybdenum (Mo)
• 0.45% Silicon (Si)
• 0.8% Vanadium (V)

D2 is categorized as a “semi-stainless” steel because its chromium content, although substantial, is slightly below the ~13% threshold that classifies a steel as fully stainless. The high carbon and chromium levels give D2 excellent wear resistance and moderate stain resistance.

2.2 N690 Steel Composition

Typical N690 compositions are:

• 1.08% Carbon (C)
• 17.3% Chromium (Cr)
• 0.4% Manganese (Mn)
• 1.1% Molybdenum (Mo)
• 0.4% Silicon (Si)
• 1.5% Cobalt (Co)
• 0.1% Vanadium (V)

With around 17.3% chromium, N690 clearly qualifies as stainless steel. Its cobalt content refines the grain structure during heat treatment, potentially improving edge stability and contributing to easier sharpening.

---

3. DETAILED ALLOY ELEMENT EFFECTS

Understanding what each element does helps predict how a steel behaves in real-world use:

• Carbon (C): Increases hardness and wear resistance. High carbon also boosts edge retention but can compromise toughness if not balanced properly.
• Chromium (Cr): Enhances corrosion resistance and wear resistance. Increasing chromium can reduce toughness if taken too high.
• Manganese (Mn): Contributes to hardenability and increases tensile strength.
• Molybdenum (Mo): Improves hardness, high-temperature strength, and corrosion resistance.
• Silicon (Si): Aids in deoxidation during steelmaking and can slightly improve strength.
• Vanadium (V): Refines grain structure, boosting wear resistance and edge stability.
• Cobalt (Co) [in N690]: Can further refine the grain and enhance overall hardness potential.

---

4. TYPICAL HARDNESS (ROCKWELL C) RANGES & PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

• D2: Often hardened to around 58–61 HRC. This range provides a balanced edge retention vs. toughness characteristic, though D2 is known more for its wear resistance rather than high-impact toughness.
• N690: Commonly hardened to around 59–62 HRC. At these levels, N690 keeps a fine edge, offers strong corrosion resistance, and has moderate to good toughness.

In practical use, both steels in the 58–62 HRC zone are suitable for day-to-day tasks—cutting, slicing, mild chopping—while being sharpenable with quality abrasives (ceramic or diamond stones).

---

5. HEAT-TREATMENT NUANCES AND FORGING

5.1 D2 Heat Treatment

D2 is an air-hardening tool steel that needs careful temperature control:

1. Preheating to ensure even temperature.
2. Austenitizing typically in the 1800–1850°F (982–1010°C) range.
3. Air cooling or oil quenching (though air cooling is more common), followed by.
4. Tempering in multiple cycles to reduce brittleness and refine the microstructure.

Because of its high carbon and chromium content, D2 can warp if overheated or quenched improperly. A stress-relief or normalizing cycle before the final austenitizing often helps minimize distortion.

5.2 N690 Heat Treatment

N690 generally requires:

1. Preheating and soaking at about 1400–1500°F (760–815°C).
2. Austenitizing in the 2000–2050°F (1093–1121°C) range.
3. Oil or air quenching.
4. Tempering to the desired hardness.

Although forging stainless steels can be tricky due to precise temperature control needs, N690 is often considered more forgiving than some higher-carbon tool steels. Its cobalt content contributes to a fine grain structure if the process is done correctly.

---

6. PERFORMANCE CHARACTERISTICS IN REAL-WORLD SCENARIOS

6.1 Edge Retention and Wear Resistance

• D2: Known for its excellent wear resistance, courtesy of the high carbon and chromium content. The presence of vanadium carbides further boosts hardness and edge stability. However, let it get too dull, and you’ll find sharpening to be more labor-intensive.
• N690: Offers good wear resistance for a stainless steel. Though it doesn’t form extremely large or super-hard carbides like some high-vanadium steels, it strikes a balance between edge retention and easier sharpening, aided by its refined grain structure.

6.2 Toughness

• D2: Considered moderately tough (not known for high-impact durability). It shines best in cutting and slicing rather than prying or heavy batoning.
• N690: Its chromium level can slightly diminish toughness compared to some lower-chromium tool steels, but it’s still regarded as having moderate to good toughness, especially for a stainless alloy.

6.3 Corrosion Resistance

• D2: Rated as semi-stainless. While better than simpler carbon steels, it can still rust or stain in humid or salty conditions if neglected.
• N690: With around 17.3% chromium, it’s considered true stainless, providing excellent resistance to rust. Ideal for kitchens, outdoors, and humid environments.

6.4 Ease of Sharpening

• D2: Scored as moderately difficult—best tackled with diamond or ceramic stones since it resists abrasion well. Beginners might find it more time-consuming to re-profile than softer or lower-alloy steels.
• N690: Generally easier to sharpen than high-carbide steels (e.g., S90V). Quality whetstones, ceramics, or diamond stones can achieve a keen edge without excessive effort.

---

7. PATINA FORMATION AND PROTECTIVE COATINGS

• D2: Being only semi-stainless, D2 can develop a light patina when exposed to acidic substances or moist environments. It won’t patina as dramatically as non-stainless carbon steels like 1095, but some darkening can occur. Protective coatings (e.g., DLC, Cerakote) can increase its corrosion resistance and reduce maintenance.
• N690: With its higher chromium content, N690 generally does not form a patina. It’s more resistant to staining and rust, so coatings are often optional unless you desire specific aesthetics or additional surface protection.

---

8. COMPARISON TABLE

Below is a quick side-by-side reference:

PROPERTY	D2 (Tool Steel)	N690 (Stainless)
Carbon Content	~1.55%	~1.08%
Chromium Content	~11.5%	~17.3%
Corrosion Resistance	Semi-stainless (moderate)	True stainless (higher)
Toughness (Scale)	Moderate	Moderate to Good
Edge Retention	Very good (high wear)	Good to Very Good
Ease of Sharpening	Moderately difficult	Generally easier
Typical Hardness (HRC)	58–61	59–62
Ideal Use	Hard-use, EDC	Kitchen, EDC, Outdoor
Cost & Availability	Usually more budget-friendly	Mid-range, slightly pricier

---

9. IDEAL USES AND WHY PICK ONE OVER ANOTHER

9.1 D2

Ideal Uses:

• EDC blades needing durable edges (e.g., utility or pocket knives).
• Semi-stainless situations where occasional maintenance is acceptable.
• Cutting tasks where wear resistance is prioritized over top-tier toughness.

Why Choose It:

• Great wear resistance at a generally budget-friendly price.
• Semi-stainless nature reduces risk of rust compared to pure carbon steels.
• Widely available and well-known among both custom and production knife makers.

9.2 N690

Ideal Uses:

• Kitchen knives requiring strong corrosion resistance and good edge characteristics.
• All-purpose EDC blades where balanced performance is desired.
• Outdoor or wet-condition knives, thanks to stainless properties.

Why Choose It:

• Offers superior rust resistance versus D2.
• Balanced edge retention, moderate toughness, easier sharpening.
• Cobalt-refined grain structure for a fine edge finish.

---

10. COST, AVAILABILITY, AND MAINTENANCE

• Cost:

  • D2 is often more budget-friendly.
  • N690 generally sits in a mid-range category, more expensive than D2 but less than top-tier powder-metallurgy steels (e.g., M390).

• Availability:

  • D2 is extremely common—seen in many production and custom knives.
  • N690 is also widely used worldwide, especially in European markets, though not as prevalent in very low-budget knives.

• Maintenance:

  • D2 requires more care to prevent spotting or rust—wipe it dry and lightly oil.
  • N690 is more forgiving around moisture, but you’ll still want to clean and dry it after prolonged use.

---

11. PROS AND CONS SUMMARY

11.1 D2 Pros

• Excellent wear resistance (high carbon, high chromium).
• Semi-stainless—less rust-prone than basic carbon steels.
• Very common, well-understood steel with many heat-treat “recipes.”

11.2 D2 Cons

• Moderate toughness; can chip under heavy impact or prying.
• More challenging to sharpen, especially if extremely dull.
• Not as corrosion-resistant as fully stainless steels.

11.3 N690 Pros

• True stainless (~17.3% chromium), significantly more rust-resistant.
• Balanced performance—good edge retention, moderate toughness, easier sharpening.
• Includes cobalt for refined grain structure, potentially smoother sharpening.

11.4 N690 Cons

• Typically more expensive than D2.
• Not as widely available in budget knife lines.
• Won’t match the extreme wear resistance of some powder-metallurgy “super steels.”

---

12. WHICH STEEL SHOULD YOU CHOOSE?

When choosing between D2 and N690, weigh your priorities for corrosion resistance, edge retention, toughness, and cost:

• D2

  • Suited for those who prioritize strong wear resistance at a lower cost.
  • Requires moderate care to prevent rust—semi-stainless only.
  • Runs at a sweet spot for budget-friendly, long-lasting edges.

• N690

  • Great for users wanting true stainless performance, particularly where moisture is abundant.
  • Balanced properties make it suitable for a broad range of tasks, from kitchen use to everyday carry.
  • Slightly higher price but still appealing if you want minimal rust worries and decent sharpening ease.

Specific Use-Case Highlights

• Durability & Toughness (Heavy Batoning/Chopping)

  • N690 generally offers slightly better impact resistance. Neither is a dedicated “impact steel,” but N690’s moderate toughness and rust resistance can be advantageous outdoors.

• Everyday Carry

  • Both are excellent choices. D2 offers extra wear resistance for frequent cutting of abrasive materials, while N690 is more forgiving in humid environments.

• Kitchen Use

  • N690’s stainless characteristic is clearly advantageous for constant exposure to moisture and acidic foods.

• Survival / Tactical

  • N690 thrives in high-humidity or corrosive environments. D2 is still viable if you’re diligent about cleaning and appreciate superior wear resistance.

---

13. CONCLUSION

Deciding between D2 and N690 ultimately comes down to how you balance corrosion resistance, edge retention, toughness, and maintenance:

• D2 is known for its cost-effectiveness, excellent wear resistance, and “semi-stainless” status. However, its moderate corrosion resistance demands a bit more upkeep in harsher climates.
• N690 offers a true stainless profile with a refined grain structure, good edge retention, and moderate to good toughness, making it a stellar all-around choice—especially if you anticipate exposure to moisture or need an easier sharpening experience.

Both steels have dedicated followings in the knife world. D2 carries the heritage of a rugged tool steel favored by many custom makers, whereas N690’s corrosion-resistance and balanced characteristics make it a top choice for those wanting a reliable, stainless all-rounder. When in doubt, match the steel to your environment and cutting tasks—and never underestimate the difference a proper heat treatment (and maintenance routine) can make.

---