CPM S60V vs CPM S30V Knife Steel Comparison

CPM-S60V vs. CPM-S30V: Which Premium Knife Steel Should You Choose?

Knife steels have come a long way, and for enthusiasts, selecting the right steel involves balancing chemistry, heat treatment, and real-world usability. Two standouts in the premium powdered-metallurgy category are CPM-S60V and CPM-S30V. Both are made by Crucible Industries using their “Crucible Particle Metallurgy” (CPM) process, which creates finely distributed carbides for enhanced wear resistance and overall performance. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll explore differences and similarities in chemical composition, hardness ranges, edge retention, corrosion resistance, and more—so you can decide which steel best fits your cutting needs.

---

1. Introduction to CPM-S60V and CPM-S30V

CPM-S30V

• Often hailed as the first high-end stainless steel designed specifically for knives.
• Boasts very good corrosion resistance, fair toughness, good edge retention, and relatively easy sharpening.
• Commonly used by custom knife makers and major production companies, making it widely accessible.

CPM-S60V

• An older formulation originally known as “440V,” later renamed to CPM-S60V.
• Offers excellent corrosion resistance, slightly lower toughness than S30V, very good edge retention, and fair ease of sharpening.
• Suited for extended cutting of abrasive materials, though less common in modern production due to the emergence of newer steels like CPM-S90V and CPM-S110V.

Both steels benefit from Crucible’s CPM technology, giving them a refined grain structure that enhances wear resistance and helps maintain consistent performance.

---

2. Chemical Composition Overview

Below are approximate values for each steel’s typical alloy composition:

Element	CPM-S30V	CPM-S60V
Carbon (C)	1.45%	2.15%
Chromium (Cr)	14%	17%
Vanadium (V)	4%	5.5%
Molybdenum (Mo)	2%	0.4%
Manganese (Mn)	–	0.4%
Silicon (Si)	–	0.4%

Note: In practice, there may be minor variations or trace elements. Always consult the particular batch specifications or the knife maker’s datasheet for exact details.

---

3. Detailed Alloy Element Effects

Carbon (C)

• Boosts hardness and edge retention.
• Higher carbon in S60V contributes to excellent wear resistance but can make sharpening more challenging.

Chromium (Cr)

• Enhances corrosion resistance and forms chromium carbides.
• S60V’s higher chromium (17% vs. 14% in S30V) further improves rust resistance in extreme conditions.

Vanadium (V)

• Forms very hard vanadium carbides, increasing wear resistance.
• S60V contains slightly more vanadium (5.5% vs. 4%), again contributing to its longer-lasting edge.

Molybdenum (Mo)

• Contributes to hardness and elevated-temperature strength.
• S30V’s higher molybdenum (2% vs. 0.4%) helps balance toughness and makes the steel somewhat easier to sharpen.

Silicon (Si) & Manganese (Mn)

• Aid deoxidation during steelmaking and can boost strength.
• Present in smaller amounts but still play a role in overall steel properties.

---

4. Typical Hardness (Rockwell C) Ranges & Practical Implication

CPM-S30V

• Commonly hardened to about 58–61 HRC.
• Maintains a good balance of edge retention and toughness, offering relatively easy field sharpening.
• Many production knives aim for ~59–60 HRC for an optimal performance-to-toughness ratio.

CPM-S60V

• Typically hardened to about 58–62 HRC.
• Achieving 61–62 HRC enhances wear resistance but may increase susceptibility to chipping under heavy stress if the heat treatment isn’t optimal.
• Higher hardness can make sharpening more labor-intensive.

---

5. Heat-Treatment Nuances and Forging

Both S30V and S60V achieve best results using precise, controlled heat treatments (often in vacuum or atmosphere-controlled furnaces):

• CPM-S30V

  • More forgiving than higher-carbide steels.
  • Typically targeted around 59–60 HRC by many makers.
  • Careful soak temperatures and correct quenching minimize warping or cracking.

• CPM-S60V

  • Requires more exacting temperature control due to higher carbon and vanadium.
  • Can demand additional normalization or sub-critical annealing steps to reduce distortion.
  • Hardness above 61–62 HRC can further raise the risk of brittleness.

Forging Note: While S30V and S60V can be forged under very specific conditions, most knife makers employ stock-removal techniques due to the steels’ high carbide content and the difficulty of forging powder-metallurgy stainless steels consistently.

---

6. Key Performance Characteristics

Corrosion Resistance

• CPM-S60V: Excellent, thanks to 17% chromium and robust carbide structure.
• CPM-S30V: Very good, though slightly lower chromium percentages mean it’s marginally less corrosion-resistant than S60V in harsh or marine conditions.

Toughness

• CPM-S60V: Fair; higher carbide volume can reduce impact resistance, raising the risk of chipping under sudden, heavy loads.
• CPM-S30V: Fair; not known for extreme toughness, but often regarded as more balanced and slightly less prone to chipping in everyday tasks.

Edge Retention

• CPM-S60V: Very good; excels in extended cutting of abrasive materials like cardboard, rope, and fibrous plant matter.
• CPM-S30V: Good; maintains a respectable edge for typical EDC and light-duty tasks, although it’s outperformed by S60V in prolonged, high-abrasion scenarios.

Ease of Sharpening

• CPM-S60V: Fair; high wear resistance means diamond stones, ceramic rods, or advanced sharpeners yield the best results.
• CPM-S30V: Good; more user-friendly for routine maintenance, though premium stones still make a difference.

---

7. Patina Formation and Protective Coatings

Neither S60V nor S30V typically forms a patina in the way high-carbon steels do. Both can remain virtually “stainless” in most conditions due to chromium content above 14%. If you want extra protection, coatings like DLC, PVD, or Cerakote can be applied, though they’re often optional given the steels’ inherent corrosion resistance.

---

8. Real-World Uses and Ideal Applications

Bushcraft and Survival

• S30V: Well-regarded for general bushcraft tasks due to its balance of sharpenability, edge holding, and rust resistance. Easier field maintenance if you only have basic sharpening equipment.
• S60V: Excellent for slicing and cutting abrasive materials. However, it’s more prone to chipping if used for heavy batoning or prying; sharpening it in the field can be challenging.

EDC (Everyday Carry)

• Both steels thrive in daily tasks like cutting open boxes, slicing rope, and light food prep.
• S60V holds an edge longer but requires more specialized sharpening gear.
• S30V is user-friendly for everyday maintenance and is typically easier to find in production knife models.

Kitchen Use

• S60V: Top-tier corrosion resistance makes it great for extended contact with acidic foods, although it may require professional sharpening services to maintain peak performance.
• S30V: Also a solid choice for kitchen knives, needing slightly more frequent touch-ups but still quite capable.

Tactical & Self-Defense

• Both steels offer reliable corrosion resistance and good edge performance.
• S60V stays sharper for longer, which may be advantageous for specialized operations.
• S30V can handle common impacts marginally better, offering a bit of a safety net against unexpected edge damage.

---

9. Cost, Availability, and Maintenance

• Cost:

  • CPM-S30V is very popular and produced in high volumes, making it more affordable and widely available.
  • CPM-S60V is less common and can be pricier due to higher alloy content and more limited runs.

• Availability:

  • Most major production brands (Benchmade, Spyderco, Zero Tolerance, and others) feature S30V in many models.
  • S60V is rarer; you might find it in older Spyderco runs or certain custom shops but it’s overshadowed by newer high-wear steels like S90V.

• Maintenance:

  • Both steels resist corrosion very well. Simple cleaning and drying prevent rust.
  • S60V demands consistent light maintenance to avoid a fully dull edge, as re-sharpening from scratch can be time-consuming.

---

10. Pros and Cons

CPM-S60V

Pros

• Top-notch corrosion resistance.
• Exceptional edge retention, suited for abrasive cutting.
• Excellent in humid or wet environments.

Cons

• Fair (not high) toughness; potential for chipping under heavy impact.
• More difficult to sharpen without proper equipment.
• Less common, often more expensive.

CPM-S30V

Pros

• Very good corrosion resistance.
• Well-rounded edge retention and toughness.
• Easier to sharpen, more user-friendly for EDC.
• Widely available and generally more affordable.

Cons

• Still not a “high-toughness” steel—extreme prying or impact can cause damage.
• Edge retention is excellent but not on par with the highest-wear steels (like S90V).
• Won’t develop a patina if you prefer a “living finish.”

---

11. Quick Comparison Table

Category	CPM-S60V	CPM-S30V
Corrosion Resistance	Excellent	Very Good
Toughness	Fair	Fair
Edge Retention	Very Good	Good
Ease of Sharpening	Fair	Good
Typical HRC Range	~58–62	~58–61
Cost & Availability	Higher cost, less common	More widely used, cheaper

---

12. Conclusions and Recommendations

Choosing between CPM-S60V and CPM-S30V depends on your priorities:

• If you want extraordinary wear resistance for cutting highly abrasive materials, paired with top-notch corrosion resistance—and you have the right sharpening tools—go with CPM-S60V. It shines in specialized applications (like extended cardboard slicing or kitchen prep with minimal rust maintenance) where you won’t be doing a lot of prying or field sharpening.

• If you prefer a more balanced steel that’s friendlier to sharpen yet still provides excellent performance across various tasks, CPM-S30V is the go-to. It’s also more budget-friendly and readily available in numerous production knife models.

Regardless of your choice, a high-quality heat treatment and proper sharpening regimen (diamond or ceramic stones) will ensure you get the best possible performance. Both CPM-S60V and CPM-S30V represent the pinnacle of modern metallurgy for knife steels, and each will serve you well if matched appropriately to your use case and maintenance preferences.